To Paint or not to paint your old toy

The Core Rule: Preserve Originality

• When it comes to repainting a vintage toy, the simple answer is: don't.

  
  

• The desirability and value of an old toy are directly linked to the amount of original paint remaining on it.

  
  

• This rule holds true even if only a small percentage of the original paint is left.

  
  

• Most serious collectors can easily spot a repainted toy.

  
  

Why Original Paint is Crucial

• The original color is a vital part of a toy's "personality" and history.

  
  

• Paint color can help identify a toy's manufacturer, as companies used their own specific shades, such as "ARCADE blue" or "HUBLEY blue".

  
  

• The colors used are often indicative of the time period when the toy was made.

  
  

• The original paint reveals the toy's story, including how it was painted (by dipping, spraying, or brush), how it was handled, and whether it was played with or stored away.

  
  

Repainting Realities

• Cast iron and large-scale steel toys, like Buddy-L, are the most commonly repainted types, likely because they were used outdoors and sustained heavy wear.

  
  

• It was common for a child to repaint a toy in a color that appealed to them more, using whatever paint was available.

  
  

• Toys made of die-cast metal or tin plate are less frequently found with repaint issues, possibly because their original vibrant colors were more accepted.

  
  

Beyond the Paint: Other Original Parts

• The principle of originality also extends to other components like chrome parts, axles, and rubber wheels.

  
  

• Stripping and re-plating chrome wheels or grilles also removes part of the toy's original character.

  
  

• Original rubber tires should be kept on the toy whenever possible.

  
  

• However, if tires are missing or in terrible condition, it is preferable to use replacements rather than display the toy on bare rims.

  
  

• For heavier toys, you can prevent flat spots on tires by displaying the toy on small blocks to lift the wheels off the shelf.

  
  

Restoration Might Be an Option

• Sometimes, layers of old, non-original paint can be removed with a paint thinner. You should always test it in an out of sight area of the toy to ensure it does not do damage to the toy.